Main Food Garden Home Celebrations Appearances Questions About Us
  Very Versatile Thumbprint Cookies

print page

close window

If you make the coconut version, we call them Coconut Cream Drops and we call the others Pecan Thumbprint Cookies.

Other flavoring or filling ideas:

Raspberry jam with sliced almonds

Lemon curd or pineapple preserves with coconut

Rum-flavored filling with walnuts and a sprinkle of nutmeg (Eggnog Thumbprints)

Or use your favorite liqueurs in place of the extracts: Chambord (with a pinch of red food coloring) and sliced almonds and a melted dark chocolate swirl on top of the filling; or Bailey's Irish Cream with hazelnuts - the possibilities are limitless!


These little cookies don’t usually last long in my house or if I take them somewhere. I prefer a coating of pecans with a vanilla cream filling, while others enjoy coconut with coconut cream filling, or others filled with chocolate or jams. Here’s the basic dough recipe:

½ cup of softened butter
¼ cup of brown sugar
1 egg separated
1 tsp. vanilla extract
1 cup flour
½ tsp. salt
1 cup of chopped nuts or flaked coconut

The hardest part of making these cookies – separating the egg! Filling ideas follow the cookie instructions. Just remember, jams are added pre-baking and frostings after.

These cookies also freeze well – bake up an unfilled batch, freeze, and when you’re ready to fill, put the frozen cookies in a 350 degree oven for 6-8 minutes to crisp them back up (not necessary, but it adds the fresh-baked touch! You can also double and triple this recipe very easily.

Here’s what you do:

1. Mix together the butter, brown sugar, egg yolk (reserve the white) and vanilla.

2. Add the dry ingredients.

3. Roll into 1 inch balls, roll into slightly whipped egg white and then in the nuts or coconut - whatever you prefer.

4. Place on cookie sheet at least 1 inch apart and press with your thumb or finger a slight indentation in the middle of the cookie. (If filling with jam, do this here.)

5. Bake at 350 degrees for 8-10 minutes until lightly golden on the bottom

6. Once cool, make the following frosting/filling and pipe into the centers:

    ¼ cup of softened butter or margarine
    2 cups of powdered sugar
    1-2 tablespoons of milk (as needed)
    and 1 tbs. of coconut extract (if your doing coconut)
    or 2 tsp. of vanilla for nuts

Yields 24-28 cookies

Copyright 2004-2008